Tintic, American Star

Index For This Page

This page was last updated on January 24, 2026.

(Return to Tintic Index Page)

Overview

(The focus of this page is the surface workings of the American Star mine, as visible in photographs, as well as a general description of the mine, with minimal coverage of the geology and financial returns. Also to establish a timeline using sources not previously readily available.)

December 10, 1909
From the Eureka Reporter, December 10, 1909.

While it is not generally known it is nonetheless a fact that the American Star, Black Bird, Triangle, Early Rose, and other claims adjoining the Eagle & Blue Bell, Victoria and Chief Consolidated holdings are just now coming in for considerable development work. Some time ago the Tintic Mines Company was organized to take over these claims and since that time an entirely new company has been organized to take the options which were held by the original company.

The new corporation is known as he American Star Mining Company and its capitalization has been placed at 1,000,000 shares of the par value of $1 each. The officers of the company are A. N. Holdaway, president; James P. Graves of Boston, vice president; Imer Pett, secretary and treasurer; and these with H. U. Hart and George Smoot constitute the board of directors.

The work which the company is now doing is handled through the Eagle & Blue Bell mine.

Mr. Holdaway, the president of the company, was in camp this week but when asked regarding the company's plans he had but little to say except that he was more than pleased with the prospects of opening up another big mine. He considers the ground which the new American Star company is working the most valuable undeveloped section of Tintic. The claims are owned by local people who have already received substantial payments. Other payments will become due early in the new year and here appears to be absolutely no question but what the new company is in position to come through with the coin.

(A. N. Holdaway was an associate of the Snyder family when they organized the North Lily company in 1916.)

(Read more about James P. Graves and Imer Pett)

December 22, 1909
From the Salt Lake Tribune, December 22, 1909.

According to the report of Manager A. N. Holdaway of the American Star Mining company, operating in the Tintic district, made at a recent meeting of the directors, considerable work has been accomplished in the development of the property since operations were commenced early in the summer. Some l,000 feet of underground drifts have been completed, and underground and surface surveys for the purpose of locating a suitable site for the sinking of a permanent working shaft have been accomplished.

The American Star claims are situated between the Chief Consolidated and Victoria properties and adjoining the Plutus on the east and the Eagle and Blue Bell on the west, the work to date having been performed through the Eagle and Blue Bell shaft. The operating company of which Mr. Holdaway is president and James P. Graves of Boston is vice president has already made payments on the ground and spent in development $20,000, and it is stated that there is $5,000 in cash and 675,000 shares of stock for a working capital still in the treasury. There are also some options on the ground yet to be paid off.

January 5, 1910
"Work accomplished comprises about 1,000 feet of drifting, which was done from the 900-foot level of the Eagle & Blue Bell workings." (Salt Lake Herald, January 5, 1910)

January 20, 1910
"The American Star Mining company yesterday made final payment for its Town View and Town View Fraction claims, in Tintic district, the entire purchase price of which was $22,500. The company owns options to purchase two adjoining groups of claims, but those for which clear deeds have now been obtained are regarded as representing the choice portion of its mineralized ground. The property lies between the Victoria and Chief Consolidated mines. Large interests in the Bingham Mines company are heavy owners of American Star, and associated with them are Senator Reed Smoot, George Smoot and A. N. Holdaway. During the last year the company did considerable development work from the 900-foot level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, when was cut one of the largest and strongest mineralized zones ever opened in the Tintic district." (Salt Lake Herald, January 21, 1910)

1914
Copper Handbook, Volume XI, 1914, page 46

American Star Mining Co., Utah
Office: 403 Dooly Bldg., Salt Lake City, Utah. Mine office: Eureka, Juab Co., Utah. Imer Pett, pres, and gen. mgr.; Jas. B. Graves, vice-pres.; Fred R. Sands, sec.-treas.; preceding officers Geo. E. Davis and Thos. P. Billings, directors. Organized 1909 under laws of Utah, as successor of Tintic Mines Co., capitalization $1,000,000, shares $1 par; issued 599,500 shares. Lands, 2 claims, 25 acres, including the Town View group and other properties lying between the Victoria and Chief Consolidated mines, and touching the Plutus on the east and Eagle & Blue Bell on the west. Mine has about 1,000' of workings, made from the 900' level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, and plans a 1,100' shaft, about one-half mile southeast of the Chief Consolidated. Workings show an ore channel of about 60' width. Property considered promising.

September 17, 1914
"From the 1350 level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine a drift is now making for the American Star property. The ground is about 400 feet northeast from the Eagle. About 200 feet of this distance, or half way, has already been covered. As the men are making from 80 to 100 feet progress a month, it is calculated that the American Star ground will be reached in about two months." (Salt Lake Herald, September 17, 1914)

(No newspaper references between 1914 and 1921.)

1918
Mines Handbook, Volume XIII, 1918, page 1314

American Star Mining Co., Utah
Office: 403 Dooly Bldg., Salt Lake City, Utah. Mine office: Eureka, Juab Co., Utah. Officers: Imer Pett, pres, and gen. mgr.; Jas. P. Graves, v. p.; Fred R. Sands, sec.-treas.; preceding officers, Geo. E. Davis and Thos. P. Billings, directors. Inc. 1909, in Utah. Cap., $1,000,000; shares $1 par; issued 599,500 shares. Property: 2 claims, 15 acres, between the Victoria and Chief Consolidated mines, and touching the Plutus on the east and Eagle & Blue Bell on the west. Mine has about 1,000' of workings, made from the 900' level and 1,000' from the 1,350' level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, and is developing through the Eagle & Blue Bell, in 1917. Workings show an ore channel of about 60' width. Property considered promising.

1920
Mines Handbook, Volume XIV, 1920, page 1444

American Star Mining Co., Utah
Office: 403 Dooly Bldg., Salt Lake City, Utah. Mine office: Eureka, Juab county. Utah. Officers: Imer Pett, pres, and gen. mgr.; Geo. E. Davis, v. p.; Fred R. Sands, sec.-treas.. with Jas. P. Graves and Thos. P. Billings, directors. Inc. 1909. in Utah. Cap., $1,000,000; shares $1 par; issued 704,500 shares. Property: 2 claims, 15 acres, between the Victoria and Chief Consolidated mines, and touching the Plutus on the cast and Eagle & Blue Bell on the west. Mine has about 1,000' of workings, made from the 900' level, 1,000' from the 1,350' level and about 600' from the 1.875' level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, and is developing through the Eagle & Blue Bell, in 1919. Workings show an ore channel of about 60' width. Property considered promising.

February 16, 1921
"American Star Mining company reports property in Juab county valued at $450." (Salt Lake Tribune, February 16, 1921)

1922
Mines Handbook, Volume XV, 1922, page 1483

American Star Mining Co., Utah
Office: 403 Dooly Bldg., Salt Lake City, Utah. Mine office: Eureka. Juab county. Utah. Officers: Imer Pett, pres, and gen, mgr.; Myron K. Billings, v. p.; J. R. Brain, sec -treas., with Jas. P. Graves and Thos. P. Billings, directors. Inc 1909. in Utah. Cap. $1,000,000; shares $1 par; issued 704,500 shades. Property: 2 claims, 15 acres, between the Victoria and Chief Consolidated mines, and touching the Plutus on the east and Eagle & Blue on the west. Mine has about 1,000' of workings, made from the 900' level, 1,000 from the 1,350' level and about 2,100' from the 1,875' level of the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, through which development is being continued. Workings show an ore channel of about 60' width. Property considered promising.

August 26, 1922
The American Star mine made its first shipment of about 100 tons. The American Star is one of the subsidiary companies of the Bingham Mines company, and is located on a small tract of land owned by the American Star Mining company, wedged between the holdings of the Chief Consolidated and the Eagle & Blue Bell companies. The American Star ground is being developed through the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, on the Town View claim, at a depth of 1,600 feet. The ore carries silver, some gold, but no lead. (Deseret News, August 26, 1922)

August 29, 1922
From the Salt Lake Tribune, August 29, 1922.

Shipment of four carloads of ore during the past two weeks from the American Star Mining company's property, situated in the Tintic district, has aroused considerable interest, in local mining circles, since conditions at the mine and the well-planned policy of operation of the controlling corporation, the Bingham Mines company are of such a character as to indicate that Eureka will have another steady ore producer.

The estate of the American Star Mining company lies in the heart of what is at present the most productive portion of the Tintic district. While not large in area, it is very favorably located with respect to known ore channels and structures favorable to its mineralization. The company's holdings, which extend from Gardner canyon northerly to the southern boundary of the town of Eureka, is entirely surrounded by property of the Chief Consolidated.

Development was started about ten years ago in a northeastern direction on the 1350 level of the Eagle & Blue Bell, also controlled by the Bingham Mines company. This drift intersected the Centennial fault, near the southern boundary of tho American Star ground. Development along the fault disclosed lead-silver ore in small lenses. A large body of barren quartz was also discovered. While this development did not show a commercial deposit, the results were considered encouraging and indicated the discovery of a new ore zone. The 1875 level of the Eagle & Blue Bell was then extended through Chief Consolidated ground into the Star estate and a winze sunk to the 2025 level. Development of the Centennial fault was carried on from both the 1875 and the 2025 levels, disclosing lead-silver ore in small bunches in a number of places.

In the meantime the Chief Consolidated had established a new ore zone under the town of Eureka, with a trend toward the American Star ground. Therefore a raise was driven from 1875 level. This working intersected ore at a point 219 feet above the level. A sublevel here has developed an ore body 28 feet wide between walls, which has been drifted on for 50 feet. Although the entire deposit is not of shipping grade, workable bodies of good grade are found. From all appearances the ore is similar in general character to Tintic ore occurrences.

The American Star Mining company is a Utah corporation organized September 2, 1909, and capitalized for 1,000,000 assessable shares, having a par value of $1 per share. Of the capital stock 705,500 shares are outstanding, the remainder being in the treasury. The officers and directors are as follows: Imer Pett, president; M. K. Billings, vice president; J. R. Brain, secretary-treasurer, and James P. Graves and Thomas P. Billings, directors.

October 24, 1922
From Salt Lake Tribune, October 24, 1922.

Earnings of the Victoria and the Eagle and Blue Bell properties of the Bingham Mines company are said to be very gratifying, inasmuch as the grade of the ore is running higher. Since the American Star mine, another property in which the Bingham Mines company owns a large interest, was brought into production, a total of thirteen carloads of ore has been marketed.

The American Star deposit, it is reported, has been opened up for a distance of 110 feet on the level where it was first exposed and raised and sunk upon for about 90 feet. Although the ore is not all of high grade, the showing is believed to be of exceptional promise. New ore bins, made necessary by the increased production of the Bingham Mines properties, are being completed at the Eagle and Blue Bell mines.

March 9, 1923
Of the total of 1,402 carloads of ore shipped by the mines of the Bingham Mines company during 1922, for a total return of $910,248.16, the Victoria (Tintic) shipped 433 cars; the Eagle & Blue Bell (Tintic) shipped 463 cars; Dalton and Lark and Commercial (Bingham) shipped 474 cars; American Star (Tintic) shipped 20 cars; and the Yosemite (Bingham) shipped 7 cars. (Salt Lake Telegram, March 9, 1923)

During 1922, the Bingham Mines company continued to buy shares of the American Star company on the open market, giving it 55.4 percent control of the company. (Salt Lake Tribune, March 9, 1923)

May 11, 1923
The American Star Mining company, and its agent, Imer Pett, made application to the U. S. Land Office in Salt Lake City, for a patent on the Town View Faction Lode, Mineral Survey No. 6672. This claim was found to be in conflict with the Eagle, Survey No. 123; the Beecher, Survey No. 196A; the Dora, Survey No. 5663; the Noah, Survey No. 239; the Noah Fraction, Survey No. 6550; the Chief Fraction, Survey No. 6289; and the Silvers, Survey No. 6401. (Eureka Reporter, May 11, 1923, with weekly notices for 60 days)

(If no contest was raised during the 60 days, the patent would be issued and the conflicting claims erased.)

October 15, 1923
"Important developments are reported from the American 8tar mine at Tintic. Operations are going on through the Eagle & Blue Bell mine and a strike made some time ago has been found 160 feet further south with an improvement in the grade of the ore." (Salt Lake Telegram, October 15, 1923)

February 13, 1924
The American Star mine shipped 3,099 tons during 1923, and none during 1922. The mine produced 58,911 ounces of silver with some gold and copper. The Tesora mine was not operated. (Deseret News, February 13, 1924)

March 7, 1924
"The ore channel in the American Star mine at Tintic has been proven continuous for 390 feet. In two different traces, it widens out to 65 and 120 feet respectively." (Salt Lake Tribune, March 7, 1924)

May 16, 1924
"The American Star's new ore deposit is now producing about four carloads each week and this promises to become the most important find on Bingham Mines ground in recent years. Up to this time the ore has been mined only between the 1650 and 1700 levels and it has about same elevation as one of the big stopes in the Chief Consolidated mine, adjoining. There is ample territory both north and south of the present workings in the American Star claim to permit the following of this ore for several hundred feet." (Eureka Reporter, May 16, 1924)

July 7, 1924
For the first half of 1924, of a total of 3,288 carloads from the entire Tintic district, compared to 4,804 carloads for 1923, "The Bingham Mines company's American Star mine fell off from 24 to 3 cars in production." (Deseret News, July 7, 1924)

April 25, 1925
"The Bingham Mines company is one of the oldest mining organizations in the state. Of the Eagle & Blue Bell it owns 97.12 percent of the company's outstanding stock, and all of the American Star." (Goodwin's Weekly, April 25, 1925)

(Recall that throughout its entire period of activity, the American Star mine was always worked through the Eagle & Blue Bell mine, and never had its own shaft or hoist or any surface facility.)

(No further reference to the American Star mine after 1925, and until the company was mentioned as being among the properties purchased by the Chief Consolidated company on December 31, 1954.)

January 14, 1955
"Chief Consolidated Mining Company acquired control of Eagle and Blue Bell Mining Company and the American Star Mining Company December 31. These properties, comprising some 78 acres of ground, are of interest to Chief principally because the American Star is surrounded by Chief property and the Eagle borders the south end of Chief No. 1 mine. Both of these properties were important producers in previous years, but have been out of production since 1949. At the present time no important work is contemplated in either property, according to Cecil Fitch, Jr., vice-president and general manager of the Chief Consolidated Mining Co. He states, however, that some block leasing will be done through Chief No. 1 shaft." (Eureka Reporter, January 14, 1955)

###